I am tired, friends. And I speak to all now, myself included. These thoughts are built on past ones, simultaneously new and repetitive. They are not meant to be offensive, only helpful.
As I said, I am tired. Tired of hostility and arrogance. Arrogance and hostility that occurs now in common conversation and which begets sadness and further hostility all in the name of personal opinions. The scenario of which I speak takes place in abundance on the internet as well as in the dark corners of academia. As a result the audiences to which I speak will bleed together. (If you can't stand the heat, get out of the kitchen.)
Most of this hostility occurs in situations of opposed rightness. In other words, two parties with opposing opinions both perceiving themselves to be correct. To be even more clear, you are a part of this particular philosophical school which detests this other philosophical school. Or you believe in evolution and your opposition does not. I find the hostility that develops from these disputes depressing because oftentimes they are sparked by one of the party's earnest attempts at the discovery or sharing of "knowledge,""truth," or "belief," (I will use these terms interchangably however problematic you may perceive that to be. If this act of word swapping makes you uncomfortable, acknowledge that I am probably trying to make you uncomfortable.)
Knowledge ought to be sought for the mutual benefit of people. It ought to be sought for the benefit of others, the search for knowledge ought to imply selflessness. The structure of the American school system implies selflessness. Teachers certainly aren't in it for the money. Therefore, if one is searching for knowledge and one initiates a discusion in this search, coming to the debate with arrogance and introducing hostility is in direct conflict with the supposed goal.
If you are concerned with true knowledge you must allow youself to be wrong and allow those with confidence in perceived wrongness to be right. You must be selfless, compassionate, attentive and empathetic. If you are not all these things you are not seeking knowledge, you are seeking validation. The popularity of your opinion amongst your colleagues does not make it right, it merely means you have reached a similar opinion as the people who are similar to you. Not very extraordinary. It means you are a member of the club that is in vogue. Clubs die and the popularity or ideas die, ideas die and we die,(not necessarily in that order) and if you are not in the search for knowledge for the benefit of those who are here and those who come after, what are you doing? Answer this. Then continue on your path and converse with others.
Seeking the truth and knowledge for self gain leads to negativity, hostility, arrogance, and failure. You must seek it for others acknowledging that anything you produce will never be whole or complete and that you will be a pebble in a pyramid, or smaller still. If you acknowledge this you are a true scholar and may be of some use in society. The person who thinks they are a cornerstone is most likely unstable foundation.
The idea that the validation of our own opinion is worth disrupting the happiness of another human being is impertinent. Not to mention that your opinion is one in a sea of billions. And that your convictions of "rightness" are just as strong as your opposition's and your perceived backwards ancestors that came before you which also had billions of conflicting opinions with yours and the ones before them. That you subscribe to the opinion that is socially, politically, or otherwise accepted or not accepted is unimportant. You're probably wrong. The liklihood of you or I or our ancestors being correct is not a solid static foundation upon which a search for universal truths can be established because we are not whole, we are not static; we are products. Let us take, for example, the greek Pantheon of Gods and Goddesses. Do you believe that a person just sat down one day and created this lovely little story? I am inclined to think our ancestors had a little more appreciation for external stimulus and a little less imagination. Those perceptions of the divine were not created out of thin air, but were built upon years of thousands of individuals' thoughts, beliefs, and impartial observations. Our opinions are built the same way. And unlike the Greeks and their Gods, we often do not allow our opinions to be so inherently faulted. In other words, we do not allow our thoughts to be as faulty and fragile and temporary as the being and beings who created them.
Individuals are sets of equations strung together by chance. There are too many irregularities, too many variables to be tracked by an outside perspective and declared to be in rightness. Because we are produced by the equations of specific and singular perceived experience, genetics and environment, it is true that certain people will not be able to easily understand each other. How is introducing hostility and arrogance to this mix productive?
If you can't understand the belief and logic, the rational steps, the thoughts influenced by your oppositions current intellectual and emotional state internally as well as external stimulus from past, present and perceived future, if you cannot understand and appreciate how one human reached a conclusion and how the steps to that conclusion may prevent them from seeing the logical and rational steps behind your own conclusions, you are not really capable of understanding how the world works, are you? And further, if you dismiss an opinion or belief because you cannot trace these steps and still believe that you are right and your opposition is steeped in wrongness, you ought to be punished, for you are nothing more than a badly behaved child with no mother to scold you. You are not bigger, you are smaller than those you perceive to be smallest. You are arrogant and undeserving.
In summation, Get Over Yourself. You know nothing and the people who come after us who think that we were blind idiots will also know nothing. Does this mean we should give up the search for knowledge? No. It means that the knowledge we seek and the effort and thought formulated should be aimed at making getting along with opposition in this life a little easier. Because then, even in our wrongness, we can claim to have been good.
Musings of a Mind-Harpy
Sunday, December 25, 2011
Friday, August 13, 2010
The Deep End
Having rediscovered my love of swimming, I decided to hop into the pool this afternoon.
There was a man (who was much prettier than I will ever be) sunbathing on the side of the pool and what appeared to be a college age couple hanging around the shallow end.
They didn't appear to be using the pool for exercise purposes, so in order to annoy them the least, I kept to the deep end. Despite my efforts, the two lovebirds were clearly flustered. They stopped swimming and sat at the edge of the pool. They stared at me while I was swimming.
Awkward.
When they realized I wasn't going to be leaving soon, they laid back and stared at the sky, their feet still dangling in the pool.
I am a compulsive worrier so it is possible that I could have been misreading them, but it was very clear they were annoyed. After I sufficiently tired myself out,(trying to reteach yourself how to swim after eight years is a difficult task) I climbed out of the pool, grabbed my stuff and as I was passing the couple, (who had been intently watching me) I looked at them, smiled and said, "Sorry, I won't steal the deep end any longer." The girl turned away from me and talked to her boyfriend very much in the same way that you would turn and talk to a companion when passing a homeless person.
Now, the fact that they were annoyed is understandable. What I cannot understand is why they didn't say something if I was inconveniencing them.
I am, by nature, nonconfrontational. It's something I have struggled with. It's not a very healthy habit. It breeds passive-aggressiveness and, if one is a kind soul, can lead to being taken advantage.
Why are we so uncomfortable telling other people the Truth. Whether that be about how we feel, what we think, ect?
It's important to exercise discretion, but why on earth is it unacceptable to request that someone keep their mediocre swimming to the side of the pool instead of the opposite end? Why, if someone says something hurtful, is it easier to keep mum?
I thought it was an issue particular to females, but over the past four years of living with men, I've realized that when it comes to avoiding(sometimes necessary) confrontation, both sexes are guilty.
It's incredibly frustrating.
Is it because, as people, we have become overwhelmingly uncomfortable with each other or is it because we've become uncomfortable with ourselves?
It is unrealistic to expect people to be unfiltered, but if one cannot make a simple request of another human being without fear of being glared or snapped or shot at, there is something horribly wrong.
We should be cognizant of this.
As for me, the next time I decide to go swimming I will ask people in the pool where I will be the least intrusive. I hate being a nuisance.
There was a man (who was much prettier than I will ever be) sunbathing on the side of the pool and what appeared to be a college age couple hanging around the shallow end.
They didn't appear to be using the pool for exercise purposes, so in order to annoy them the least, I kept to the deep end. Despite my efforts, the two lovebirds were clearly flustered. They stopped swimming and sat at the edge of the pool. They stared at me while I was swimming.
Awkward.
When they realized I wasn't going to be leaving soon, they laid back and stared at the sky, their feet still dangling in the pool.
I am a compulsive worrier so it is possible that I could have been misreading them, but it was very clear they were annoyed. After I sufficiently tired myself out,(trying to reteach yourself how to swim after eight years is a difficult task) I climbed out of the pool, grabbed my stuff and as I was passing the couple, (who had been intently watching me) I looked at them, smiled and said, "Sorry, I won't steal the deep end any longer." The girl turned away from me and talked to her boyfriend very much in the same way that you would turn and talk to a companion when passing a homeless person.
Now, the fact that they were annoyed is understandable. What I cannot understand is why they didn't say something if I was inconveniencing them.
I am, by nature, nonconfrontational. It's something I have struggled with. It's not a very healthy habit. It breeds passive-aggressiveness and, if one is a kind soul, can lead to being taken advantage.
Why are we so uncomfortable telling other people the Truth. Whether that be about how we feel, what we think, ect?
It's important to exercise discretion, but why on earth is it unacceptable to request that someone keep their mediocre swimming to the side of the pool instead of the opposite end? Why, if someone says something hurtful, is it easier to keep mum?
I thought it was an issue particular to females, but over the past four years of living with men, I've realized that when it comes to avoiding(sometimes necessary) confrontation, both sexes are guilty.
It's incredibly frustrating.
Is it because, as people, we have become overwhelmingly uncomfortable with each other or is it because we've become uncomfortable with ourselves?
It is unrealistic to expect people to be unfiltered, but if one cannot make a simple request of another human being without fear of being glared or snapped or shot at, there is something horribly wrong.
We should be cognizant of this.
As for me, the next time I decide to go swimming I will ask people in the pool where I will be the least intrusive. I hate being a nuisance.
Wednesday, July 7, 2010
This Music is Too Loud
I was having a girls night out and by some strange coincidence, my lady friends and I picked a bar that our friend hosts at on Wednesday nights. I was recently tattooed on Monday; I got a yin and yang right below my thumb on my right wrist. I asked him what he thought and his facial expression said it all,
"Really? You got a yinyang on your wrist? Who are you?"
I then spent a great deal of time explaining why I wasn't a loony for getting such a mundane symbol on my wrist. Because while the ink and the image are only a few hundred layers of cells deep, the meaning goes much deeper.
The problem is:
People will judge me if they don't know my story.
Of course that's the same issue I have with all my tattoos. A butterfly on my back, a heart on my thigh and a music note on my left arm. I've been attacked numerous times for having cliched tattoos. They're shallow images. They require no work, no effort to uncover their meaning.
Perhaps. Or perhaps I don't want people to know what's deeper. That is what I usually say.
"I never have to explain what they mean if I don't want to," I say, "They can just think it's a cliche if they want to."
But then why do I insist on explaining my yinyang to my darling hipster? I would like to think it's because he is my friend and I wouldn't want him to think I'm a loony. But I think this is merely an example of a greater problem:
People will judge me if they don't know my story.
And I have to wonder, does anyone really know my story? I can definitively say that none of the friends I've made in college truly know my story. Not for any particular reason. Sometimes because I never had a chance to tell, other times because I didn't want to.
What about my darling sisters of Regina? They are probably the closest to knowing my story to the fullest, but they have only skimmed the past few chapters due to distance and busy schedules. And because of that, some of the major scenes are out of context...
Does anyone ever really know your story? Probably not. That's not a bad thing. It's just how it is.
When was the last time that you read a book from cover to cover? How much do you remember? Certainly not every word. So even if someone has read your story cover to cover, every page, they don't know it.
But we aren't trying to get people to read our stories. We're not out there trying to get published. We aren't actively trying to get people to read our story.
Or are we?
Maybe the blackened and burned skin cells on my body are silent calls for a question, a conversation. A chance to tell my story.
"That's what I like about my tattoos. They're plain and cliched, so I never have to explain them to people if I don't want to."
And I usually don't.
So people sans the story may judge as they like.
As they tend to, tattoos or not.
"Really? You got a yinyang on your wrist? Who are you?"
I then spent a great deal of time explaining why I wasn't a loony for getting such a mundane symbol on my wrist. Because while the ink and the image are only a few hundred layers of cells deep, the meaning goes much deeper.
The problem is:
People will judge me if they don't know my story.
Of course that's the same issue I have with all my tattoos. A butterfly on my back, a heart on my thigh and a music note on my left arm. I've been attacked numerous times for having cliched tattoos. They're shallow images. They require no work, no effort to uncover their meaning.
Perhaps. Or perhaps I don't want people to know what's deeper. That is what I usually say.
"I never have to explain what they mean if I don't want to," I say, "They can just think it's a cliche if they want to."
But then why do I insist on explaining my yinyang to my darling hipster? I would like to think it's because he is my friend and I wouldn't want him to think I'm a loony. But I think this is merely an example of a greater problem:
People will judge me if they don't know my story.
And I have to wonder, does anyone really know my story? I can definitively say that none of the friends I've made in college truly know my story. Not for any particular reason. Sometimes because I never had a chance to tell, other times because I didn't want to.
What about my darling sisters of Regina? They are probably the closest to knowing my story to the fullest, but they have only skimmed the past few chapters due to distance and busy schedules. And because of that, some of the major scenes are out of context...
Does anyone ever really know your story? Probably not. That's not a bad thing. It's just how it is.
When was the last time that you read a book from cover to cover? How much do you remember? Certainly not every word. So even if someone has read your story cover to cover, every page, they don't know it.
But we aren't trying to get people to read our stories. We're not out there trying to get published. We aren't actively trying to get people to read our story.
Or are we?
Maybe the blackened and burned skin cells on my body are silent calls for a question, a conversation. A chance to tell my story.
"That's what I like about my tattoos. They're plain and cliched, so I never have to explain them to people if I don't want to."
And I usually don't.
So people sans the story may judge as they like.
As they tend to, tattoos or not.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)